"Frank Scarso Finds His Life," by Doug Crandall, in Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine, May/June 2021.
Walter Mosley, who knows a thing or two about writing fiction, said "Story is what happens. Plot is when the reason it happens or the reasons that it happens are revealed to the reader."
In other words, you don't necessarily want to have the beginning, middle, and end of your story in that order.
The first thing we learn in this tale is that whatever occurs in it lands our protagonist in prison. And he doesn't seem to be too upset about that.
Frank Scarso was in prison before because of a tragic mistake he made. Now, in his sixties, he is looking for a chance to do a little good. In a word, he is hunting for redemption.
He gets a job in a home for kids with serious problems and finds himself oddly bonding with an autistic boy whose life has been one horror after another. Frank thinks he can maybe help, and if that brings him grief, so be it...
What does Crandall gain by putting the cart before the horse, so to speak, telling us how Frank's story will end? I will paraphrase another author, Jean Anouilh, who said the difference between tragedy and melodrama is that we know how tragedy will end, so the struggle to survive takes on a sort of nobility. We know where this is going but it is a fascinating trip...
